By Aaron Miller-
People who catch Covid-19 are more likely to go on to suffer depression and anxiety, a study has suggested. Experts said the research backs up previous findings but has a longer follow-up, with people tracked for a year.
The study has a major downside in its failure to distinguish between different impacts of Covid-19 on different people, nor does it tell us the demography of people who participated in the research in terms of other underlying issues or comorbidities they may have had before catching the virus.
AD: Capeesh Restaurant
A major weakness of the research is its failure to distinguish people with Covid-19 who were asymptomatic9showed no symptoms) and those who were symptomatic(had the predicted symptoms). Even among symptomatic individuals exists different levels of symptoms, the highest category being those who were hospitalized by the virus, more so in the context of other underlying issues present.
The highly imperfect research whose findings still holds some value within potentially limited theoretical scope, bundles all of those who had suffered from Covid-19 with no underlying issues , with those who suffered from the virus but also had underlying issues. A further draw back of the research is its failure to include various age groups of those comprising the research, making it not very complete in the accuracy of its information or any proper analysis of it.
US researchers who conducted the study, looked at data for 153,848 people who had experienced coronavirus and compared them with more than 560,000 with no history of Covid ,and a further large control group from before the pandemic.
AD: Oysterian Sea Food Restaurant And Bar
The results showed that Covid-19 was associated with an increased risk of mental health problems, including anxiety, depression, substance use and sleep problems, up to a year after infection.
Compared with the non-infected group, the findings of the research revealed that people with Covid-19 showed a 60% higher risk of a mental health diagnosis or needing a mental health prescription at the one-year point.
Anxiety rates were 35% higher among those who had had Covid and 39% higher for depression. People were also 55% more likely to use anti-depressants.
Sleep Disorder
Researchers found that having had Covid meant the equivalent of an extra 24 per 1,000 people suffered a sleep disorder, an extra 15 per 1,000 had depressive disorders, and an extra four had substance use problems. Similar results were found when the Covid-19 group was compared with the pre-pandemic group. The risks were highest in people admitted to hospital but were still apparent in those who recovered at home.
Those with Covid-19 were also more likely to suffer mental health problems than patients with flu, while Covid patients who ended up in hospital were more likely to suffer mentally than those admitted for any other reason.
Researchers used data from the US Department of Veterans Affairs and published their work in the BMJ. Most of those in the study were men with an average age of 63.
The experts, including from Saint Louis University, concluded: “The findings suggest that people who survive the acute phase of Covid-19 are at increased risk of an array of incident mental health disorders. “Tackling mental health disorders among survivors of Covid-19 should be a priority.”
Dr Adrian James, president of the Royal College of Psychiatrists, said: “These findings drive home how a Covid-19 infection can have a devastating and long-lasting mental health impact on people.”
He said other studies have shown that one in three patients put on a ventilator suffer post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD), while others have long Covid.
Dr James said “many people face an uphill battle to rebuild their lives,” adding: “Treatment is vital but complicated by the reality that most people experiencing mental health difficulties after infection don’t seek help.
“Actively monitoring the recovery of patients through a ‘screen and treat’ programme can help make sure they get the right kind of mental health care at the right time.”
The study strengthens the growing evidence base on the need to invest in mental health as part of strategies for social and economic recovery from the pandemic
Dr Nilu Ahmed, University of Bristol
‘Paul Harrison, professor of psychiatry at the University of Oxford, said: “The study builds on prior work of this kind, which had shown that Covid-19 is followed by an increased risk of common mental disorders, more so in those hospitalized during the acute infection.
“The main advance of this study is that it extends the follow-up period to 12 months.”
Dr Nilu Ahmed, behavioural psychologist at the University of Bristol, said: “The study strengthens the growing evidence base on the need to invest in mental health as part of strategies for social and economic recovery from the pandemic.
“We are still learning about the effects of long Covid, which is resulting in poor mental health as well as physical health, and this study adds to this by highlighting it is not just long Covid that increases the risk of mental health issues.”
People who have suffered from Covid should not automatically expect to suffer depression or increased anxiety, unless they actually observe both mental health conditions in operation.
The downside to fully embracing imperfect research is the risk of putting a self fulfilling prophecy in operation by adopting a belief system that may not necessarily apply to one’s individual situation.
AD: Heritage And Restaurant Lounge Bar