Judge’s directions place six womens allegations under scrutiny as case reaches final stage

Judge’s directions place six womens allegations under scrutiny as case reaches final stage

 

By Lucy Caulkett-

The high-profile criminal trial of Russell Brand has entered its closing stages, with the jury being given important legal directions by the judge as it prepares to consider seven criminal charges involving six women.

Brand, 51, denies three counts of rape, three counts of sexual assault and one count of attempted indecent assault. The alleged offences are said to have taken place between 1999 and 2009. The judge’s summing-up is particularly significant because it directs jurors on how they must approach the evidence, the credibility of witnesses, inconsistencies in accounts and the burden of proof.

Capeesh Restaurant

AD: Capeesh Restaurant

One of the central points emphasised by the judge was that the prosecution must prove its case. Brand is not required to prove his innocence, and the jury must consider each of the seven charges individually. The judge also addressed the considerable passage of time between the alleged incidents and the trial.

Jurors were reminded that the allegations relate to events many years ago, meaning memories may have faded and evidence may be difficult to obtain. Importantly, they were told to consider whether the delay had placed Brand at a serious disadvantage and, if so, to take that into account in his favour.

Oysterian Sea Food Restaurant And Bar

AD: Oysterian Sea Food Restaurant And Bar

The judge also made clear that a delay in reporting an alleged sexual offence does not automatically mean an allegation is false. Equally, an immediate complaint does not automatically establish that it is true. On inconsistencies in the women’s accounts, jurors were told that differences in recollection can occur whether someone is telling the truth or not. They must therefore assess the evidence as a whole rather than dismiss an account simply because there are discrepancies.

Brand’s character and credibility

The jury was also directed on the issue of Brand’s good character. The judge explained that Brand’s lack of significant previous convictions could be considered when assessing his credibility and the likelihood of him committing the alleged offences. He said it makes it more likely than not that a person of good character is telling the truth than not.

However, the judge stressed that good character does not provide a defence to the charges.  He  also told the jury  not to assume that because the alleged victims had come many years after the alleged incidents that their allegations are untrue.

Evidence from Brand’s wife and former partners was also relevant to this consideration. They had described positive aspects of his character and their experiences of consensual relationships with him.Another important issue raised in the judge’s directions concerned Brand’s police interviews.

The jury was reminded that Brand had been interviewed between November 2023 and July 2025 and had provided prepared statements, saying he had nothing further to add when questioned about the specific allegations.

The judge explained that jurors could consider his failure to mention certain details during those interviews if they believed he had subsequently relied upon those details in court. However, this was not an automatic finding against him. The jury must decide why the information was not mentioned earlier and whether any adverse conclusion is justified.

The prosecution’s case

Prosecutor Riel Karmy-Jones KC told the jury that the case involved six women who did not know one another. The prosecution argued that their accounts shared significant similarities, particularly their descriptions of Brand’s behaviour changing during encounters and their allegations that he continued despite their objections.

The prosecution also challenged the suggestion that the 2023 Channel 4 Dispatches documentary had influenced the women to make false allegations. Its position was that the documentary had encouraged women who had previously felt isolated to come forward and report their experiences.

The prosecution urged jurors to examine each woman’s account and the circumstances surrounding the individual allegations. Brand took the witness stand and firmly denied the allegations. He told the jury that consent was fundamental to him, describing it as more important than sex itself.

He acknowledged that he had been promiscuous, persuasive and reckless in his younger years and admitted that he had used his fame to facilitate sexual encounters, which he now regarded as wrong. However, he maintained that the sexual encounters in question were consensual and denied committing any criminal offence.

During cross-examination, the prosecution challenged Brand’s recollection of events and questioned why certain details had emerged in his evidence that had not appeared in his earlier police interviews. Brand described the allegations and their consequences as devastating to his personal and family life.

Closing the prosecution case, Riel Karmy-Jones KC told the court that this case brings together six different women, none of whom knows each other. none of them has “sought the limelight” or “any kind of publicity”, she said, adding that there is no benefit to them except perhaps some closure.

y”Listen to their accounts,  she said, how many said he was nice, then there was a personality change, a pivot.” His eyes changed, he snapped, from charming to frightening to nasty,” she adds.

She said all the alleged victims have since moved on with their lives, but due to this trial they have been forced to “relive what has happened to them” and describe the most intimate details to the court.

The jury’s responsibility

The judge made clear that the jury must reach unanimous verdicts. All 12 jurors must agree on whether Brand is guilty or not guilty of each charge.

The jury must decide the case solely on the evidence presented in court and the judge’s legal directions, rather than media coverage, public opinion or speculation.

Reference was made to prepared statements  by the former comedian to the police during his interviews,  during which when asked about the specific allegations said he had nothing to add.

The jury  was told that Brand did not tell present to police  accounts he now relies on in respect of the three rape allegations, and they are told that part of their job is to assess his reasoning for not mentioning further facts in his interviews.

The judge says: “These failures to set out his case may harm his defence if you conclude that he failed to mention these facts in interview because he did not have an answer at the time of interview, he had no answer that he then believed would stand up to questioning, or he has invented this account after the interview.”

Judge Bennathan also told jurors they must not assume the delay in making complaints to the police makes the allegation untrue.

“All of the allegations to police were delayed by many years,” he says.

“On the delay in making the complaints to the police, you must not assume that was because they are untrue. The fact that a complaint is made late does not make the allegation untrue, just as a complaint is not necessarily true just because it was made immediately”, he said

Heritage And Restaurant Lounge Bar

AD: Heritage And Restaurant Lounge Bar

 

Spread the news

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *