Lord Young’s Intervention In Oxford Uni Protest Alongside 27 peers raises questions about Tory Stance

Lord Young’s Intervention In Oxford Uni Protest Alongside 27 peers raises questions about Tory Stance

By Gabrtel Princewill

A letter to Thames Valley Police, signed by 27 peers and led by the Free Speech Union’s general secretary, has brought attention to the controversy surrounding Coffman’s invitation to speak in Oxford, raising wider questions about freedom of expression, institutional responsibility and the right to host controversial speakers.

Lord Young of Acton,(pictured) general secretary of the Free Speech Union, has intervened in the controversy surrounding protests against a speaking engagement involving Coffman in Oxford, writing to the chief constable of Thames Valley Police in a letter supported by 27 peers. Among the signatories is Baroness Deech, former principal of St Anne’s College, Oxford University. The letter accuses the police of having failed to protect the rights of ticket holders and maintain public order, placing the conduct of the authorities under scrutiny and reigniting debate about the boundaries of freedom of expression.

Capeesh Restaurant

AD: Capeesh Restaurant

At the centre of the controversy is a question that goes beyond the immediate circumstances of the Oxford protests. exactly what it means to defend freedom of speech when the individual invited to speak holds views that are  offensive , and likely to provoke strong opposition. There is no legal right for a member of the British public not to be offended by an offensive view except if it breaks the law.

Mark , a 37 year old  waiter from Leyton, told The Eye Of media. Com: ” I don’t think its proper for a professor to be sharing such views, but he should have the right under freedom of speech to say whatever he wants. that’s the whole point about free speech. if people don’t agree with it, they can express their disagreement.  People will find it offensive, but if the professor states his reasons for the opinion, and they are genuine reasons, even if they are wrong, it’s fine”.

Sharon , a 23 year old sales assistant, also from Leyton said: ”I think a man who spreads such a view is dangerous and boarders on hate speech. and should not be allowed to express those views on a public platform. Views that are hateful should not be encouraged because they foster division in society. providing a platform  to a man who spreads views that one race has superior intelligence than other races contaminates the integrity of the speech”

Oysterian Sea Food Restaurant And Bar

AD: Oysterian Sea Food Restaurant And Bar

Another member of the public, Marcus, 38,from  Bethnal Green  said: ”I think people are allowed to express whatever views they want, even if offensive. People can then react to it as they please, by challenging those views. I think the professor should be allowed to express his views , if he truly believes them, and is not just expressing them to be controversial. His motive  matters. One has to listen to everything he says, every single thing. But it is right that he is allowed to express his views”.

Lisa, a 16 year old G.C.S.E pupil, stopped in Bethnal Green, said : ”I don’t think a professor should be allowed to claim Freedom of Speech when it comes to opinions to do with race and intelligence. Freedom of speech has terms and conditions, and you can’t have people saying things so far reaching if they cannot prove it in an evident way that cannot be disputed. I feel like freedom of speech has to have terms and conditions”.

Jason, 41, also Bethnal Green said: ” I think it is wrong for a man expressing such views to be given a platform to express such views because they insinuate a hatred for a particular race. He may dress it up as expressing his right to freedom of speech, but freedom of speech has boundaries. It cannot be right or justified for an academic to be allowed to spout views that reflect his hatred for a particular race. Even if the platform for counterviews is provided, that man, especially an academic, is expressing views that can influence people to treat people of a particular race in a discriminatory way, because superiority based on race eventually translates into condescending attitudes towards people of that race, which can escalate to practical racism. It is wrong to provide platforms to individuals who express those views”

Variations of freedom of speech were then presented to each of the individuals questioned to examine the consistency of their positions. they were asked if freedom of speech can be extended to allow an individual approach them in the present of their partner, and say ” I think you have bad taste for your selection of a partner. They look awful” but I am expressing my right to free speech”. All of those questioned who supported free speech, said this example would be provocative and therefore unacceptable. ”The difference here is that the free speech was designed to be  offensive and  provocative, Sharon said. When  reminded that, some of thee views could equally be provoking, she conceeds it is a tricky question.

Marcus  said : ‘the hypothetical scenario is different because the person is infringing the right of the couple by approaching them with unflattering words. Asked if it is not considerably unflattering for a white professor to express views of superior intelligence of his race over the black race, and if their right to be respected for their human race is not an infringement, he responds: it can be viewed as such depending on how exactly he says what he says, and how provocative it actually is”.

He admits it is not ideal for a professor to be expressing such views on a public platform/ he reviews his opinion slightly and says : I think people are still free to say what they want, but there may be consequences for what they say.” The guy approaching me with his partner is free to insult my partner with his words, but I could punch him if I am willing to risk being arrested. Or put another way, a random person hearing him may choose to attack him for it. So there may be consequences to free speech, depending on the speech”.

When asked whether they knew freedom of speech is a qualified right, under the Human Rights Act 1998, all of those questioned above said they were not aware of this fact. Yet, there appears to be no  precise consensus on the benchmark underpinning any qualified right offree speech.

 

Academic Nathan Cofnas who accused Jason Arday of plagiarism suspended by university

Controversial: Nathan cofnas invitation to speak at Oxford university sparked protests 

So have the Tory Peers revealed their support for Cofnas to express his views, or do they necessarily support those views, and  should there consequences for it? Andy, a 36 year old IT engineer said: ” the actions taken by Lord Young and the other peers does not prove that they support Coffman’s views. It may demonstrate their commitment to free speech the way they understand it. it says nothing of their own views, but suggests they tolerate his views being made public”. Asked if it suggests that the peers believe Cambridge University was wrong to sack the professor, he responds: ‘that is probably a logical deduction”.

Lord Young’s intervention places the Oxford controversy within a much larger debate about the relationship between freom of speech, the right to protest and the responsibilities of public institutions. His letter suggests support for protecting the opportunity of Coffman and his audience to participate in the speaking event, although it does not establish agreement with the speaker’s views or explicitly endorse the original invitation.

 More specifically, does defending the rights of ticket holders and criticizing the police response amount to an implicit defence of the decision to invite Coffman in the first place?  There is a compelling argument that Lord Young’s intervention is consistent with the principle that the freedom to express opinions must include the freedom to invite controversial figures to express theirs, no matter how wrong or divisive it is.

The difference here is  between defending someone’s right to speak and endorsing what they say. Nothing in the wording of the letter provided establishes that Lord Young or the 27 peers necessarily agree with Coffman’s arguments, racial theories or wider ideological positions. Their stated criticism concerns the alleged failure of the police to protect ticket holders and maintain public order. Nevertheless, their intervention raises legitimate questions about whether they consider the original invitation itself to be protected by the principles of freedom of expression they are defending.

However, the matter becomes complex when the description of a speaker as a racial realist enters the debate. The expression raises uncomfortble  questions about race, ideology, academic freedom, and the limits of acceptable public discourse. Those who defend the right to invite such a speaker may argue that controversial ideas should be confronted through criticism, evidence and open debate rather than prevented from being heard. This view is not illogical at all.

Critics already   argue that providing a platform to particular viewpoints can legitimize ideas they regard as harmful or discriminatory. Both the decision to invite a speaker and the decision to protest against that invitation are  matters that deserve scrutiny.

However, opposition to a speaker and the prevention of a speaking engagement are not necessarily the same thing. Peaceful protest is an important democratic right, and those who object to a speaker are free to communicate their objections. Equally, those who have purchased tickets should not automatically lose their opportunity to attend an event simply because the speaker has attracted controversy. The challenge for the authorities is to protect lawful protest while ensuring that intimidation, disorder or unlawful obstruction does not determine who can speak and who can listen.

This is where Lord Young’s criticism of Thames Valley Police becomes particularly significant because the  allegation that officers failed to protect ticket holders and maintain public order accentuates the practical responsibilities of the police when competing rights collide. Police forces are expected to manage public demonstrations, safeguard individuals and respond appropriately to disorder. They are also expected to operate within the law and respect the rights of those participating in both the event and the protest.

Nevertheless, his actions can be interpreted as revealing his own leaning in this controversial issue. The involvement of 27 peers also gives the letter a wider political and constitutional significance. Their collective support indicates that the concerns raised by Lord Young have attracted attention beyond the immediate dispute. Baroness Deech’s participation is particularly notable given her association with Oxford University and her former position as principal of St Anne’s College.

 

The National Jewish Assembly Welcomes Baroness Ruth Deech DBE KC As Honorary President - National Jewish Assembly

Baroness Deech was one of signatories

Deech is a trained lawyer who worked as the first Independent Adjudicator for Higher Education (2004–2008) and chaired the Bar Standards Board  between 2009 and 2014. She was also a Gresham Professor of Law at Gresham College. It is hardly conceivable that the lawyer does not know that freedom of speech is a qualified right. Could it be that her intervention is a reflection of her leaning in support of Cofman’s views? Yes and No.

In many respectYes, because she is cognizant of his views and the potential those views are reflective of his wider outlook on ethnic minorities. No, because she may either be oblivious of the qualifying right of free speech notwithstanding her broad legal background, or she may merely be paying allegiance to those who are rigid adherents of the notion of free speech, irrespective of the potential shortcoming in their views. In many respects, the respective views of individuals and organisations are premised on a highly subjective value judgement.

Nevertheless, the number and standing of the signatories potentially makes the topic and associated arguments more serious. There is also a broader issue about consistency in the defence of free speech. If the principle is that speakers should be permitted to express controversial opinions, that principle is expected to be capable of applying beyond popular or politically convenient viewpoints.

 Most will agree that freedom of expression protects, disagreement as well as the expression of the original opinion. Yet, when the viewpoints expressed by the speaker are not only especially offensive, and the speaker is known to be racist, this can be a problem.  but is believing that white people have superior intelligence to black people necessarily a racist view?

The question that remains is whether the 27 peers see the right to invite Cofnas as an essential part of the freedom of expression they are seeking to defend. Their intervention has brought that question into sharper focus. In a democratic society, controversial speakers must be open to criticism, their arguments must be open to challenge and peaceful opponents must retain the right to protest. But the decision about which voices can be heard should not ultimately be determined by the threat of disruption. The test of a genuine commitment to free speech is whether the same principles are defended even when the speaker, the subject and the arguments are deeply unpopular.

The wider implications for Oxford and freedom of expression

The Oxford controversy highlights the responsibilities of universities and other institutions that provide spaces for public discussion. Academic freedom and freedom of expression are central to intellectual inquiry, but they are not without boundaries. Institutions are expected to balance the right to explore controversial ideas against their responsibilities to protect members of their communities from discrimination, harassment and unlawful conduct. The challenge is  ensuring that these responsibilities are not used indiscriminately to suppress legitimate debate.

Most of those spoken to consider there to be a difference  between allowing a speaker to address an audience and giving institutional approval to the speaker’s opinions. An invitation does not automatically amount to an endorsement. Equally, permitting a controversial event to proceed does not prevent an institution, its academics or its students from challenging the arguments presented. Indeed, open disagreement can provide a more meaningful test of controversial claims than an attempt to prevent their expression altogether.

There is also a question for those opposing the invitation. If they believe Cffman’s arguments are fundamentally flawed, discriminatory or unsupported, what better opportunity could there be to expose those weaknesses through rigorous questioning and public scrutiny? Peaceful protest remains entirely legitimate, but intellectual disagreement should not be confused with the right to prevent others from listening.

The Oxford dispute illustrates the tough relationship between the right to speak, the right to protest and the responsibility to protect both. Neither side should be expected to surrender its lawful freedoms simply because the other considers its position objectionable. The strength of democratic institutions is measured not by their ability to avoid controversy, but by their capacity to manage disagreement without abandoning the principles they are supposed to uphold.

Heritage And Restaurant Lounge Bar

AD: Heritage And Restaurant Lounge Bar

Spread the news

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *