By Aaron Miller-
A federal judge has cleared the way for E. Jean Carroll to receive millions of dollars awarded after a jury found former President Donald Trump liable in a civil case involving sexual abuse and defamation. The ruling marks another major development in a long-running legal battle that has followed Trump for years and continued through multiple appeals.
U.S. District Judge Lewis A. Kaplan ordered the release of approximately $5.8 million held for Carroll, representing the original $5 million jury award plus interest accumulated since the verdict. The money had been placed into a court-controlled account while Trump pursued appeals challenging the judgment. The order came after the U.S. Supreme Court declined to hear Trump’s appeal of the original civil verdict.
AD: Capeesh Restaurant
The case began after E. Jean Carroll, a writer and former Elle magazine columnist, accused Donald Trump of sexually assaulting her in the 1990s at a New York department store. Trump denied Carroll’s allegations and repeatedly criticised her after she publicly shared her account. In 2023, a civil jury found Trump liable for sexually abusing Carroll and defaming her through comments he made after she went public with the accusation, ordering him to pay $5 million in damages.
The verdict marked a significant legal defeat for Trump, while emphasising that the case was a civil matter rather than a criminal conviction. Unlike a criminal conviction, the verdict came from a civil lawsuit, where jurors considered whether Trump should be held financially responsible for harm caused by his actions and statements.
The decision became one of the most closely watched legal outcomes involving a former U.S. president, placing questions of accountability, public speech and the limits of personal attacks at the center of national debate.
AD: Oysterian Sea Food Restaurant And Bar
Trump has continued to deny Carroll’s allegations and has challenged the verdict through the courts. His legal team argued that the judgement should not be paid out while additional appeals remained possible, but Judge Kaplan ruled that the conditions allowing the release of the funds had been met after the Supreme Court’s decision not to review the case.
A Long Legal Battle Reaches a New Stage
The payment order represents a significant moment in a legal dispute that has unfolded over several years and multiple court proceedings. E. Jean Carroll first sued Donald Trump in 2019 after he publicly denied her allegations and accused her of fabricating the claim.
The initial lawsuit focused on defamation because Carroll was challenging Trump’s public statements about her accusation rather than pursuing the underlying assault claim at that stage. The case later expanded after changes in New York law allowed Carroll to bring a separate civil claim related to the alleged sexual assault.
A later lawsuit brought under New York’s Adult Survivors Act allowed Carroll to pursue claims related to the alleged assault itself. That case resulted in the 2023 jury verdict, which found Trump liable and awarded Carroll $5 million in damages for sexual abuse and defamation.
The legal dispute did not end with that decision. Trump appealed, arguing that the trial court had made errors and that he should have been allowed to present additional arguments. However, the appeals process continued without overturning the jury’s findings, and the Supreme Court’s refusal to hear the case removed another potential avenue for delaying enforcement of the judgement.
Carroll’s attorneys argued that the time had come for the funds to be released after years of litigation. They maintained that the judgement had already been secured and that further delays were unnecessary. Trump’s lawyers, meanwhile, sought to prevent the payment from being transferred while they pursued additional legal options.
The ruling also comes as Trump faces a separate financial judgement connected to Carroll. In a different defamation trial in 2024, a jury awarded Carroll an additional $83.3 million after finding Trump liable for further defamatory statements. That award remains subject to a separate appeals process.
Together, the two cases represent one of the largest legal challenges involving Trump outside of criminal proceedings. They have also become a major point of political controversy, with Trump describing the lawsuits as politically motivated while Carroll and her legal team have argued that the verdicts represent accountability through the civil justice system.
The release of the payment does not necessarily end the broader legal conflict. Trump has indicated that he intends to continue challenging aspects of the rulings, including through additional appeals. However, the judge’s decision means Carroll can now collect the money awarded by the jury rather than waiting for the conclusion of every remaining legal argument.
Legal experts note that civil judgements are generally enforceable even while appeals continue, particularly when courts determine that adequate financial protections are already in place. In this case, the funds had already been deposited during the appeals process, allowing the court to authorise their transfer after the Supreme Court declined to intervene.
With Carroll, the decision represents the latest chapter in a public battle that began when she accused one of the most recognisable political figures in the world of sexual misconduct. She has said that pursuing the case was about defending her reputation and seeking accountability after Trump repeatedly attacked her publicly.
The case remains part of a broader series of legal disputes that have shaped his political career and public image. His supporters have argued that the lawsuits against him are unfair, while critics say the verdicts demonstrate that even powerful public figures can be held responsible through the courts.
The case has also renewed discussion about how civil courts handle allegations involving prominent individuals and how victims of sexual misconduct seek justice when criminal prosecution does not occur. Carroll’s lawsuits have drawn attention to the challenges survivors often face when allegations involve powerful figures and when years have passed since the alleged events.
The immediate issue of the $5.8 million payment has moved from uncertainty to resolution. A federal judge has ruled that Carroll is entitled to collect the damages awarded by the jury, bringing one stage of the dispute closer to a conclusion. However, the case remains part of a much larger legal and political story. With another substantial judgement still under appeal and Trump continuing to challenge the outcomes, the fight between Trump and Carroll is likely to remain in the public spotlight.
AD: Heritage And Restaurant Lounge Bar