By James Simons-
A man alongside three of his acquaintances, have been found cock fighting during a visit to a house in Seven Kings, Redbridge last January.
51 year old Mohammed Asab, 51, was found guilty of causing an animal fight to take place, keeping and training an animal for use in connection with an animal fight, and keeping premises for use for an animal fight.
Three other men, including 47 year old Akhtar Hussain of Greenhill Grove, and a 17-year-old, who cannot be named for legal reasons, were also convicted of being present at an animal fight involving cockerels.
Convicting them, District Judge Gary Lucie said: “There is no direct evidence that a cock fight took place on January 2, that is true. No eyewitnesses saw cock fighting taking place.
“The prosecution relies on circumstantial evidence that it took place and it is often thought that circumstantial evidence is wrong.
“Whilst a piece of circumstantial evidence may be insufficient, each piece can be seen a strand of rope.
“And with each piece the stronger the rope becomes until the evidence can be seen to prove the case to the criminal standard.”
Police searching Asab’s home found an injured cockerel inside a grey cat box, with blood and feathers splattered across the walls while another cockerel roamed freely.
AD: Capeesh Restaurant
Ten cockerels, two hens, two mobile phones, equipment associated with cockfighting and a blood covered towel were seized and removed from the scene. Asab claimed in his defence, that he kept the birds to show as champions, eating the ‘left overs,’ and explained that the one in the cat box had been attacked by a fox.
Asab explained that he placed the bird inside the cat box to give to his co-defendant 54 year old Altaf Hussein, who had travelled from Coventry to meet him for the first time. However, Judge Lucie dismissed this argument in his closing speech.
He said: “Firstly, [Asab and Altaf] didn’t know each other. Why would Hussain want to take a bird that was suffering with injuries and ridden with mites?” His denial of any cockfighting took place was irrational and not very believable. He said:
“We were just talking and singing and having a chat.”
“I was singing before they arrived and even when they were there I was still singing.”
Hazel Stevens, Prosecutor for the RSPCA, Hazel Court, presented ta photo found on Asab’s phone, taken on Christmas Day.
The photo showed four of the men on trial at Mr Asab’s home with one man, Mehtab Ahmed, being referred to as the “Grand Master” and clasping a cockerel statue in his hands.
AD: Oysterian Sea Food Restaurant And Bar
Mr Ahmed explained that he this nickname was given to him sarcastically by being forced to sing by the other men, despite having a “normal” voice. He added: “I’m not interested in fighting. I don’t like it.”
Mr Lucie addressed the men’s explanations for this photo with incredulity.
He said:
GATHERING
“I accept that there had been no character explanation and I would be unable to conclude that there had been a cock fight that day.”
“But there clearly was a gathering of people who have an interest in keeping fighting cockerels.
“It was of a group presenting a cockfighting trophy to a grand master cockfighter.
“The idea that you win a cockerel for being the worst singer in the room is an insult to my intelligence.”
“The fact that he had them to sell as champions when he has never entered them into a competition let alone won any competition.”
Mohamed Arif, 43, of Fairfield Road, Ilford; Mehtab Ahmed, 41, of Celebration Way, Chingford; and Altaf Hussain, 54, of Parkstone Road, Coventry, were all found guilty of being present at an animal fight involving cockerels.
AD: Heritage And Restaurant Lounge Bar