By Isabelle Wilson-
Caleb Flynn looked, to those outside his marriage, like the kind of man few people would instinctively fear. He was a husband, father, church leader and former television talent-show contestant. Yet prosecutors said that behind the respectable public image was a man conducting an affair, expressing hatred towards his wife and ultimately killing her in the family home.
His conviction and life-without-parole sentence raise an uncomfortable question every woman in America in particular, but anywhere the world really, should ask themselves that reaches far beyond one Ohio courtroom.
Exactly how can someone know whether the person they are choosing to spend their life with could one day become lethally violent, or even become their own killer. There is clearly no psychological test that can tell a woman, or a man, that the person sitting opposite them across a restaurant table is secretly a future murderer.
There is no single facial expression, personality trait, profession, religious belief, childhood experience or romantic habit that turns an apparently ordinary partner into a predictable killer. That is precisely why the research into intimate-partner homicide is so unsettling. The strongest evidence does not point to a mysterious “killer personality”. Instead, it points towards patterns of behaviour: coercive control, threats, stalking, previous violence, sexual violence, strangulation, threats involving weapons, access to firearms and an escalating determination to control a partner who is trying to leave.
And sometimes the warning signs are not dramatic enough to look like the beginning of a murder story. They may begin with the partner demanding passwords, deciding who the other person can see, becoming furious when messages are unanswered, monitoring movements, humiliating their partner, controlling money, threatening self-harm if the relationship ends, or repeatedly insisting that nobody else can be trusted.
One controlling incident does not mean that a person will become a murderer. Most people who behave badly in relationships will never kill their partners. But researchers have identified combinations of behaviours that should be treated as serious danger signals rather than dismissed as evidence of an intense or passionate relationship. That distinction matters because the most dangerous relationships are not necessarily the ones that look frightening from the outside.
A major meta-analysis examining research on intimate-partner homicide found that some of the strongest risk factors included the perpetrator having access to a gun, previous non-fatal strangulation of the victim, previous rape, threats involving a weapon, controlling behaviour and threats to harm the victim.
The research drew together 17 studies and 148 effect sizes. In other words, psychologists and violence researchers are not telling people to search for a stereotypical “monster”. They are telling them to pay attention to behaviour.
. One of the most important findings is that violence does not have to begin with an attempted murder before it becomes dangerous. Controlling behaviour can be part of the pathway. A partner who insists on knowing where the other person is at all times, isolates them from friends and family, controls finances or repeatedly undermines their independence may be establishing something much more serious than ordinary relationship insecurity.
Researchers have also found a particularly troubling association between stalking and lethal violence .In a study involving 821 women, researchers found that women whose abusive partners followed or spied on them were more than twice as likely to be victims of attempted or actual femicide. Threats to harm children if the woman left or refused to return to the relationship were associated with a ninefold increase in the risk of attempted or actual femic.
That makes one of the most persistent romantic myths particularly dangerous. The idea that obsessive behaviour is simply evidence of how much someone cares. It is not. A partner who constantly checks your location is not necessarily protective. A partner who demands access to every private conversation is not necessarily devoted.
A partner who says he cannot live without you may not be expressing the depth of his love. In some circumstances, such behaviour is about possession and control. Perhaps the most counter-intuitive finding in the research is that danger can increase when an abusive relationship is ending.
A study of domestic homicide reviews in England and Wales found that separation, stalking and a victim entering a new relationship were important risk factors. In the 263 cases examined, 40 per cent of victims had separated from their partner or were about to do so during the two months before the homicide, while 24 per cent were experiencing stalking or harassment.
The researchers found that where separation had occurred, the average interval between separation and homicide was approximately two months. A partner who puts their hands around someone’s neck, restricts their breathing or otherwise attempts to strangle them has crossed a particularly serious line.
Research has identified previous non-fatal strangulation as one of the strongest risk factors for intimate-partner homicide. That is why the phrase “he only strangled me once” should never be allowed to minimise what happened. It is not simply another argument that got out of hand. It is a potentially lethal act.
The conviction of Caleb Flynn provides a particularly stark illustration of the gulf that can exist between public image and private behaviour. Flynn, 40, was sentenced in Ohio on October 5 to life imprisonment without the possibility of parole after a jury convicted him of murdering his wife, Flynn, 37.
Prosecutors said he shot Ashley while she was sleeping and then staged the scene to resemble a burglary. Flynn maintained his innocence at sentencing and said he had not killed his wife, despite being convicted by the jury. The case also involved an affair with a former church intern, and prosecutors presented messages in which Flynn discussed his desire to be free of his marriage and told the woman he was having an affair with, shortly before Ashley’s death, that he was choosing her and was free.
The tragedy is not evidence that an affair makes somebody a murderer. It plainly does not. Nor does it establish that a person who lies, cheats or wants a divorce is necessarily violent. The significance is much narrower and more important: in a case in which a husband was ultimately convicted of murdering his wife, prosecutors described a progression involving deception, an affair, expressed hostility towards his wife and an apparent desire to escape the marriage without accepting the consequences of doing so lawfully. That is a lesson about behaviour and circumstances, not a psychological diagnosis of every unfaithful spouse.
The statistics reveal who is most at risk
According to the U.S. Bureau of Justice Statistics, the overall rate of homicide victimisation by an intimate partner in 2023 was 0.7 per 100,000 people. The rate for women was 0.9 per 100,000, compared with 0.5 per 100,000 for men. Intimate partners in the federal statistics include current or former spouses, boyfriends and girlfriends. The CDC’s National Violent Death Reporting System provides an even more revealing picture.
In 2023, among female homicide victims for whom the victim-suspect relationship was known, approximately 53.4 per cent had a current or former intimate partner identified as the suspect. Among male homicide victims for whom the relationship was known, the comparable figure was 6.9 per cent.
That is an extraordinary sex difference. But there is an important statistical caveat. The relationship between victim and suspect was known in only 59.6 per cent of female homicides and 32.6 per cent of male homicides in the CDC’s 2023 dataset. The figures therefore should not be presented as though they identify every intimate-partner killing in America.
The 2022 CDC figures tell a similar story. Intimate-partner violence was identified as a precipitating circumstance in approximately 41.8 per cent of female homicides, compared with 8.0 per cent of male homic The conclusion is not that men are incapable of being victims .Men certainly are. It is that women face a substantially greater risk of being killed by an intimate partner than men do, and that the sex difference is sufficiently large that it cannot responsibly be ignored in reporting on domestic homicide.
The major federal datasets measure different things. The Bureau of Justice Statistics reports homicide victimisation and victim-offender relationships; the CDC reports violent deaths and circumstances; and the FBI’s NIBRS system contains information on victims, known offenders, relationships and arrests. None of these should simply be converted into a national tally of people imprisoned for intimate-partner murder.
There is another reason for caution. A homicide victim does not necessarily correspond neatly to one convicted offender, cases may involve multiple offenders, prosecutions occur in different years from the killings, and convictions can be for different offences.
The most defensible U.S. statistics are therefore homicide victimisation statistics, not claims about the number of men and women “jailed” in a particular year. The most important lesson from the research may be the one readers least want to hear.
Experts warn that one cannot reliably identify a future intimate-partner murderer by appearance. Forensic psychologist, Dr Wendy Elliott, told The Eye Of Media.Com: ”future murderers are not always easy to spot at first glance.
They can be appear in different shapes and sizes. They can be charming, religious, successful, and appear extraordinarily loving during the early stages of a relationship. None of those characteristics provides immunity against violent behaviour.
That is why psychologists focus on patterns, particularly patterns of domination and escalation. A person considering a lifelong relationship should be much more interested in how a prospective partner behaves when told “no” than in how beautifully he behaves when everything is going his way.
‘How they react when a partner disagrees with them, whether they accept boundaries, and can apologise without blaming someone else are useful indicators of whether an individual is level headed or not in a relationship. Some men become incredibly frightening when angry, or damage property in a dispute.
The evidence does not suggest that every person displaying one of these behaviours will become a murderer. Rather, what it says is that those behaviours should not be romanticised, minimised or explained away when several occur together.
The question every prospective spouse should be asking
Dr Elliott continued: ”Perhaps the most revealing test of a prospective life partner is not how passionately he loves you. It is how they behaves when he cannot have what he wants, and the extent to which he accept your independence. His level of tolerance of rejection is also important, and can be a telling sign.
Can he accept that you have friends he does not know, opinions he does not share and boundaries he cannot cross. Whether he can lose an argument without trying to punish you and can hear the word “no” without turning it into an insult, a threat or a campaign of intimidation? The answers will not predict the future with certainty. No psychological research can do that.
”But the science increasingly shows that intimate-partner homicide does not simply materialise from nowhere. In many cases, there is a history of coercion, threats, violence, stalking or other warning behaviour.
In the English and Welsh domestic-homicide research, coercive control and physical and psychological abuse were each present in roughly half of the cases examined, while separation and stalking were particularly important features in the period immediately preceding some killings
. The devastating lesson of cases such as the Flynn murder is therefore not that women should learn to recognise a killer’s face. It is that nobody should be persuaded to ignore frightening behaviour simply because the person displaying it can also be charming, successful, respectable, religious, romantic or publicly adored.
”A murderer may not look like a murderer. But control, intimidation, stalking, strangulation, threats and escalating violence are not harmless quirks of an imperfect romance. They are behaviours that deserve to be taken seriously — especially when the person a claim such as “X men and Y women were jailed for killing their partners in America last year” into the article unless you have a specific state-by-state: none of these behaviours proves that someone will kill, and presenting them as a fool proof “killer checklist” would go beyond what the psychology supports displaying them believes that losing the relationship means losing control of the person in it.
In 2023, the U.S. intimate-partner homicide rate was 0.9 per 100,000 for females versus 0.5 for males, while the CDC found that, where the relationship was known, 53.4% of female homicide victims had a current/former intimate partner identified as the suspect, compared with 6.9% of male victims”.



