By Tony O’Riley-
Around 1,000 former rugby players pursuing claims over serious head injuries have been ordered to make immediate payments totalling more than £1.5 million towards the defendants’ legal costs, after the High Court raised concerns over the handling of the long-running group litigation.
The claimants must pay a 60% pro rata interim chunk of the rugby union defendants’ costs, alongside 75% of the rugby league’s costs.
The claimants, drawn from both rugby union and rugby league, allege that repeated collisions and impacts suffered during matches and training contributed to serious neurological injuries.
This initial interim payment must be made within 14 days, the court said. The judge stated that the steep financial penalties are a direct consequence of a “contradictory and misguided approach” by the players’ former legal representation, Rylands Garth, who were replaced by KP Law.
The defendants, which include the governing bodies of the sport, dispute the claims and maintain that appropriate measures have been taken to reduce the risk of neurological injury.
Hundreds of claimants are currently struck off from the action after being found in breach of a court order requiring them to disclose all available documents relating to their neurological testing.
They also challenge the claimants’ arguments on causation, both in relation to the wider case and the circumstances of individual players.
Following a half-day hearing on Friday, Senior Master Cook, sitting with Mr Justice Cotter and Master Stevens, made an order in an ex-tempore judgment, requiring the claimants to pay substantial sums towards the defendants’ costs, as a condition of being granted relief from sanctions.
The court heard that the defendants are seeking costs of more than £2.8 million. Costs for the Rugby League proceedings were put at approximately £252,000, of which the court ordered 75 per cent to be paid as an interim payment.
In relation to the Rugby Union proceedings, the costs claimed were said to total around £2.5 million. That figure comprised approximately £628,000 claimed by World Rugby Limited, £874,000 by the Rugby Football Union and £1.09 million by the Welsh Rugby Union Limited.
Having considered the information available to the court, Senior Master Cook ordered that 60 per cent of those sums should be paid on account by the claimants, pro rata between the defendants.
The judge stressed that the figures before him were not yet definitive, and remained subject to a detailed assessment. The payments are to be made within 14 days, with the defendants’ costs to be assessed on an indemnity basis.
The ruling followed an apology from Paul Downes KC, who has recently been brought into the case to represent the claimants. Addressing the court, Downes acknowledged concerns surrounding the way the litigation had been handled and said his approach was one of contrition rather than explanation.
“I have been recently brought in, my concern is to strike the right tone,” he told the court. “The tone is one of contrition, not explanation. We apologise to the court and apologise to the defendants. I fully accept that does not make it right but it seems to me the correct starting point.”
Senior Master Cook said there was ultimately agreement between the parties on the basis upon which the court should approach the application for relief from sanctions.
He made clear that the relief would be conditional upon the claimants meeting the defendants’ costs.
Compliance With disclosure
The court has also ordered the claimants to comply with all previous orders concerning disclosure by the end of the month, adding a further deadline to proceedings that have already faced significant procedural difficulties.
The consequences of failing to comply are potentially severe, because in any event that the claimants fail to meet the requirements of the latest order, their claims are expected to be struck out.
The defendants have until 6 November to make an application for a strike-out. The litigation represents one of the most significant legal challenges faced by the governing bodies of rugby over the alleged long-term consequences of repeated head impacts.
While the claimants argue that serious neurological injuries were caused or contributed to by exposure to collisions during their playing careers, the defendants continue to contest both the underlying allegations and the evidence linking rugby participation to individual injuries.
The immediate issue remains procedural, rather than the ultimate question of liability. The claimants must meet the court-imposed deadlines and make substantial payments towards the defendants’ costs if the wider litigation is to continue.
Failure to do so could bring individual claims to an end before the court reaches a final determination on the substantive allegations.
If the outstanding documents are not disclosed and the costs are not settled by the end of October, hundreds of affected players will see their claims permanently struck out.



