By Ben Kerrigan-
The future of jury trials in England and Wales remains uncertain after the new Lord Chancellor declined to rule out further restrictions, leaving open the possibility that judges could gain greater control over whether defendants are tried by a jury or alone.
Alex Norris, appointed Lord Chancellor and Secretary of State for Justice by Prime Minister Andy Burnham in July, was pressed in the Commons on Tuesday over whether the government intends to continue with proposals to reduce the use of jury trials.
Rather than offering a guarantee that the right would be protected, Norris said the new government would examine the Ministry of Justice’s work before deciding how to proceed.
The exchange comes as the Courts and Tribunals Bill prepares to return to the Commons on 13 October for its report stage and third reading.
The Bill was originally introduced under the previous government and former Lord Chancellor David Lammy, and contains some of the most significant proposed changes to the criminal courts in decades. Parliament’s official timetable confirms that amendments can be considered when the Bill returns.
The immediate political question is whether Norris and Burnham will retain the Bill’s existing jury provisions, modify them or introduce further changes.
Conservative MP Dr Neil Shastri-Hurst told the Commons that reports suggested ministers were considering an amendment under which, for offences that can currently be tried either in a magistrates’ court or the Crown Court, a judge could decide whether the defendant should face a jury or a judge sitting alone.

Conservative MP Dr Neil Shastri-Hurst
Norris did not confirm the reported proposal, cautioning MPs against relying on reports and saying that the government would set out its position from the dispatch box when it had something to announce.
Pressed by shadow justice secretary Nick Timothy for a commitment that the Bill would not restrict jury trials, Norris again stopped short of giving one.
He argued that Parliament should be allowed to consider the legislation through the normal stages, and noted that Bills frequently change during their passage. His response leaves the government with room to alter the legislation before MPs vote on its final form.
The existing Bill already proposes a substantial change. Under current arrangements, an adult charged with an either-way offence can, in certain circumstances, elect to have the case heard in the Crown Court, where it would normally be decided by a judge and jury.
The government’s Bill would remove that right where magistrates accept jurisdiction, leaving the courts to determine where the case should be heard. It would also establish a new Crown Court Bench Division for either-way offences likely to result in a custodial sentence of three years or less. Those cases would be heard by a judge alone.
Separately, the Bill proposes judge-only trials for suitably technical and lengthy fraud and financial cases, subject to specified conditions.
The government says the changes are intended to reduce pressure on the Crown Court and reserve jury trials for the most serious cases. The reforms are being advanced against the backdrop of an acute backlog in the criminal courts.
The government’s own figures put the Crown Court’s open caseload at 79,619 cases in September 2025, more than double its 2019 level. Ministers have argued that investment alone cannot resolve the problem and that structural reform is also necessary. The Bill draws heavily on recommendations from Sir Brian Leveson’s Independent Review of the Criminal Courts.
The proposals have nevertheless faced sustained opposition from sections of the legal profession. The Law Society has argued that restricting jury trials could affect fairness and public confidence and has questioned whether the changes would produce significant reductions in the backlog.
Its written evidence to Parliament said removing defendants’ ability to elect a Crown Court trial could have serious implications for the justice system.
The dispute reaches beyond the immediate question of court administration because jury trial has a long and complicated place in Britain’s constitutional history. The right originated directly in Magna Carta, sealed by King John at Runnymede in 1215.
The historical reality is more nuanced: because the House of Commons Library notes that Magna Carta did not itself establish trial by jury, although its guarantee of judgement according to law and by one’s peers later became closely associated with the development of the principle.
The modern jury system evolved over centuries, with important developments under the medieval kings.
The independence of juries acquired particular constitutional significance in the 17th century. In Bushell’s Case of 1670, juror Edward Bushell challenged his imprisonment after a jury refused to convict Quakers William Penn and William Mead.
The case established that jurors could not be punished by a judge simply for returning a verdict according to their conscience, becoming an enduring reference point for the independence of juries from judicial and state pressure.
The modern framework is considerably more complex. Jury service in England and Wales is now principally governed by the Juries Act 1974, while the current right for defendants charged with triable either-way offences to elect Crown Court trial is rooted in legislation including the Magistrates’ Courts Act 1980.
The system therefore reflects centuries of development rather than a single constitutional rule handed down unchanged from medieval England.
The government’s case is that the proposed reforms would allow courts to direct cases to the most appropriate venue, freeing Crown Court capacity for serious offences and reducing delays for victims, witnesses and defendants. The government estimates that judge-only trials would take at least 20 per cent less time, drawing on Sir Brian Leveson’s anal
Critics argue that changing the mode of trial risks solving one pressure in the system while creating others.
The Law Society has questioned the likely scale of efficiency gains and warned of additional complexity. The disagreement is therefore not simply about whether juries are efficient; it is about how far Parliament should alter the balance between administrative speed, judicial decision-making and citizen participation in criminal trials.
What is clear is that the issue will return to the centre of parliamentary debate when the Courts and Tribunals Bill comes back to the Commons on 13 October.
After eight centuries of evolution, the jury remains embedded in the architecture of English and Welsh justice — but its place in the criminal courts is once again being tested.



