By Lucy Caulkett-
A Magistrate judge has received a formal warning for misconduct after repeatedly making comments to HM Courts and Tribunals Service (HMCTS) staff that were found to have gone beyond reasonable criticism, raising fresh questions about the standards of professionalism and courtesy expected of judicial office-holders. Michael Dunstan was sanctioned after an investigation found that his written and verbal communications with the HMCTS magistrates’ expenses team had repeatedly challenged the integrity, professionalism, impartiality and competence of officials.
The complaint alleged that Dunstan had questioned the conduct and judgement of HMCTS staff while suggesting that he had been victimised in connection with decisions concerning his expenses claims. According to the Judicial Conduct Investigations Office (JCIO), some of his communications were considered to border on harassment, although no finding of harassment was made by the investigation. judges right from the Magistrates Court. all they way up, wield enormous power and influence in the judicial system. High power can sometimes lead to self serving, entitled or inflated behaviour, and this can at times cross boundaries.
The offending Magistrate, Dunstan, denied engaging in inappropriate conduct or discriminatory behaviour. He maintained that his comments arose from genuine concerns about decisions relating to his expenses claims. However, the investigation found that, although he was entitled to raise concerns and challenge decisions, the manner in which he communicated those concerns crossed the boundaries of acceptable professional conduct.
The JCIO said Dunstan had repeatedly made comments that challenged an HMCTS official’s integrity, professionalism and judgement. It added that he accepted that one particular issue was not attributable to the official concerned and apologised. The investigation concluded that his conduct did not amount to harassment but was sufficiently serious to constitute misconduct.
The formal warning comes despite Dunstan having maintained an otherwise unblemished conduct record for more than 23 years. The investigation acknowledged his lengthy record of service but concluded that this did not remove the responsibility to communicate appropriately with those working within the justice system. The findings stressed that legitimate criticism and professional disagreement are not prohibited. Judicial office-holders are expected to express concerns in a manner that demonstrates fairness, respect and professionalism. In this case, the investigation found that Dunstan’s comments went beyond what could reasonably be considered legitimate criticism and failed to treat the HMCTS official with the fairness, respect and professionalism required of someone holding judicial office. Mr Justice Keehan, acting on behalf of the Lady Chief Justice and with the agreement of the Lord Chancellor, issued Dunstan with a formal warning.
The case comes against a wider background of disciplinary action involving magistrates across England and Wales. Figures published in the Judicial Conduct Investigations Office’s 2024–25 annual report show that 52 magistrates were found to have committed misconduct and received disciplinary sanctions during that reporting year. This represented an increase from 36 magistrates in 2023–24, an increase of 16 cases, or approximately 44 per cent. The 2024–25 figures included 17 cases resulting in formal advice, 17 formal warnings, five reprimands and 13 removals from office. The figures demonstrate the range of disciplinary outcomes available where misconduct is established, from formal advice at the lower end of the scale to removal from the magistracy.
Importantly, these figures cover the 2024–25 reporting year and should not be interpreted as a confirmed total for the 12 months preceding Dunstan’s November 2026 sanction. The JCIO has emphasised that disciplinary sanctions are intended to uphold public confidence in the judiciary and reinforce the standards expected of those entrusted with judicial responsibilities. The Guide to Judicial Conduct makes clear that judicial office-holders must treat others fairly and respectfully and conduct themselves professionally and courteously. The accompanying Statement of Expected Behaviour also reminds magistrates and other judicial office-holders to consider how their words and actions may affect those around them.
Magistrates are expected to maintain appropriate standards when dealing with court staff, colleagues, members of the public and other professionals involved in the administration of justice.The principles are particularly important given the responsibilities magistrates hold and the public trust associated with their position. Although magistrates are entitled to raise concerns about administrative decisions, expenses, working arrangements and other matters affecting their judicial duties, the disciplinary framework makes clear that such concerns must be communicated appropriately.



