By Kenneth Williams-
ENSENADA, MEXICO — A man accused of murdering Australian brothers Jake and Callum Robinson and their American friend Carter Rhoad was an assassin who routinely carried a gun and kept a list of people he intended to kill, a Mexican court has heard.
The stunning allegation was made by Ari Gisell, the former girlfriend of Jesús Gerardo, also known as El Kekas, as she gave evidence at the trial in Ensenada on Monday. Gerardo is one of three men facing charges over the deaths of the three surfers, who were killed during a surfing and camping trip in Baja California in April 20234
Gisell told the court that Gerardo later described the killings to her and mocked the victims’ distress. According to her evidence, he said the men had handed over their car keys and wallets, and begged not to be killed. One of the victims allegedly pleaded that he should not be killed because he had a wife, Gisell told the court. She said Gerardo responded afterwards by joking about how the victims had cried.
The testimony offers one of the most detailed accounts yet heard publicly about the moments surrounding the deaths.But the evidence presented in court does not establish that Gerardo had been specifically assigned to kill Jake and Callum Robinson or Carter Rhoad.
Instead, the prosecution case reported to date has centred on an alleged robbery that turned deadly, with the victims apparently targeted after the group encountered them at the isolated Punta San José surfing location. Gisell told the court that she, Gerardo, another woman and the son of Gerardo’s former girlfriend encountered the three tourists at their remote campsite.
The court heard that Gerardo asked Gisell to approach the men and ask for fuel because their vehicle was running low. She described the Australians and Rhoad as kind and friendly and said they offered to share their fuel, although the group could not siphon it from the vehicle.
Gisell recalled telling Gerardo that the tourists had good tyres and good phones, while insisting that she was not encouraging him to rob them The group subsequently left the beach. Gisell said Gerardo later told her he intended to “f*** up the gringos”.
The son of Gerardo’s former girlfriend allegedly took a shirt to cover his face because it was going to be his “first job”, according to Gisell’s testimony. The men subsequently returned to the campsite.
Gisell told the court that Gerardo and the other man later came back in the tourists’ vehicle, which she said was splattered with blood. Gerardo allegedly returned carrying three phones and two chain necklaces, while his boots were covered in blood, she testified.The tourists’ vehicle was subsequently found burned out.
Perhaps the most striking part of Gisell’s evidence was her description of Gerardo as a hit man with a list of people he intended to kill. She told the court that he was always armed and that she was frightened of him because of his reputation for violence.
But she did not say that Gerardo had been commissioned or ordered by another person to assassinate the three men.
The three men on trial
Gerardo is standing trial alongside Irineo Francisco and Ángel Jesús. The three men face charges including aggravated homicide, aggravated robbery, violent robbery and grand theft auto.
The trial began in Ensenada earlier this month. Proceedings have already been complicated by witness-safety concerns: prosecutors told the court that witnesses had been intimidated, and at one stage the defendants were removed from the courtroom while evidence was given.
Gisell herself is not on trial for the murders. She was sentenced in November 2025 to 20 years in prison after being convicted of offences connected with the robbery. Prosecutors described her as the instigator of the robbery that led to the deaths.
Her evidence is therefore particularly significant but must be treated as testimony from a convicted participant and former partner of one of the accused, rather than an established account of what happened. However, it can still be treated seriously if deemed plausible.
Jake and Callum Robinson, brothers from Perth, had travelled to Baja California with their American friend Carter Rhoad for surfing and camping. The three disappeared in April 2024. Their bodies were subsequently discovered in a remote well, while their vehicle was found burned.
Mexican authorities claimed the trio were attacked and killed over their truck’s tires.callum10robinson/Instagram
The case shocked both Australia and the United States and prompted intense scrutiny of the circumstance. Now, more than two years after the deaths, the trial is finally examining the evidence against the three men.




